November 19, 2026 Filing & On-Site Records Audit: Case No. 2025-CP-10-05095
This page hosts the native-digital, as-filed copy of Plaintiffs' November 19, 2026 Plaintiffs' Notice of Court Response to Demand for Visibility and Direct Native-pdf Docketing Parity (with exhibits A, B, C, and D) in McNeil & Poyer v. SAC 181, LLC, et al. (Charleston County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. 2025-CP-10-05095), together with the records-retention packet provided by Clerk of Court staff during Plaintiffs' contemporaneous in-person audit.
It is posted here so that anyone running across the filing in degraded form on the Charleston County, SC 9th Circuit Court of Common Pleas docket has access to a full-quality version they can search the text in, copy-paste from, and see in full quality. It also gives the crawlers for AI, legal software, and search engines ingestible text without the need for resource-intensive and error-prone optical text recognition (OCR), which they generally won't use.
Further, it makes the filing available in full native quality for immediate review by the Court, appellate reviewers, journalists, and the public.
- Plaintiffs' Notice of Visibility & Electronic Docket Access Disparity (As-Filed, Nov. 19, 2026: 53 Pages, Exhibits A-D)
- Records-Retention Packet Provided by Clerk Staff (2014 SCDAH Letter & S.C. Code Ann. § 26-6-120: 4 Pages) & Statutory Comparison Table
- Access to Justice Builds Stronger Courts: Empirical, Systems-Thinking & Institutional Context
- Related Resources & Primary Court Dockets
Plaintiffs' Notice of Visibility & Electronic Docket Access Disparity (As-Filed, November 19, 2026)
Filed in person at the Charleston County Clerk of Court on November 19, 2026, this 53-page submission documents the operational gap between attorney e-filing (native PDF ingestion and immediate docket visibility) and the paper-only workflow required of self-represented litigants. It includes the main Notice (pp. 1-12), Exhibit A (U.S. Supreme Court Supplemental Brief, No. 26-562, docketed Nov. 17, 2026, pp. 13-35), Exhibit B (SC Court of Appeals Notice of Appeal, No. 2026-002110, pp. 36-40), Exhibit C (Oct. 23-26, 2026 correspondence regarding digital filing parity, pp. 41-45), and Exhibit D (Plaintiffs' signed contemporaneous Nov. 19, 2026 on-site counter inspection and audit notes, pp. 46-53).
Unable to view the pdf on your mobile device?
Download the PDF
Records-Retention Packet Provided by Charleston County Clerk Staff (SCDAH Letter & S.C. Code Ann. § 26-6-120)
back to top
During the November 19, 2026 counter inspection (which included approximately 45 minutes of back-office consultations by Clerk personnel), staff confirmed that original paper filings submitted by self-represented litigants are retained on-site for only 30 days after scanning before destruction, and provided Plaintiffs with this 4-page packet: an April 9, 2014 letter from Richard Harris of the South Carolina Department of Archives and History (SCDAH) to Chief Justice Jean Hoefer Toal regarding electronic imaging and paper-record disposition (pp. 1-2), paired with the text of S.C. Code Ann. § 26-6-120 (pp. 3-4). For full statutory and archival context, compare this packet with S.C. Code Ann. § 14-17-510, S.C. Code Ann. § 14-17-570, SC Clerk of Court Manual § 3.1.3, SCDAH Public Records Information Leaflet #13 (April 2024), and SCDAH Form ARM-13 in the side-by-side comparison below.
Unable to view the pdf on your mobile device?
Download the PDF
Side-by-Side Comparison: What the Provided Packet States vs. South Carolina Law & Archival Policy
Readers can evaluate how the 2014 packet handed out at the counter aligns with the governing statutes, clerk manual, and SCDAH digital-imaging requirements by comparing the primary text directly:
| Issue |
What the Provided 2014 Packet States |
What South Carolina Law, Regulation & Policy State |
| Accuracy, Legibility & Visual Inspection |
The attached text of S.C. Code Ann. § 26-6-120(A) states that an electronic record satisfies a retention law only if it "accurately reflects the information in the record after it was first generated in its final form as an electronic record or otherwise" and "remains accessible for later reference." The 2014 letter acknowledges Chief Justice Toal's certification that Judicial Department digital systems meet the seven criteria in Public Records Information Leaflet #13. |
SCDAH Public Records Information Leaflet #13 (April 2024) Criterion 5 requires custodians to "Verify that imaged records have been visually inspected and are legible and correct during initial digitization process." SCDAH Form ARM-13 requires an authorized representative to certify in writing "that the digital image records have been visually inspected and are legible and correct." |
| Advance Written Disposal Authorization (Form ARM-13) |
The 2014 letter itself states: "If, at some point, the custodian of the records decides to destroy original paper documents that have been converted to digital format, the records custodian or their authorized representative should complete and submit to the Department of Archives and History an Authorization For Disposal Of Original Paper Records Stored As Digital Images form (form ARM-13)... Following approval by this Department, the authorization form will be returned to the records custodian for implementation." |
SCDAH Leaflet #13 Criterion 7 mandates that custodians "Obtain an authorization for disposal of original records in advance from the South Carolina Department of Archives and History." Form ARM-13 states: "THIS FORM IS USED TO DESTROY ORIGINAL PAPER RECORDS NOW DIGITIZED AND TO DESIGNATE THE ELECTRONIC COPY AS THE OFFICIAL VERSION OF THE RECORD," requiring agency-specific approval, off-site security copy verification, and signed disposal dates. |
| Scope of the 2014 Letter vs. County Paper Scanning |
The April 9, 2014 letter is addressed to Chief Justice Jean Hoefer Toal regarding digital records in "those systems hosted by the South Carolina Judicial Department" (Appellate CMS, Bar Admissions, Trial Court CMS, and SC Courts E-Filing). |
S.C. Code Ann. § 26-6-120(G) (printed on pages 3-4 of the Clerk's own packet) specifies: "This section does not preclude a governmental agency of this State from specifying additional requirements for the retention of a record subject to the agency's jurisdiction." County clerk retention schedules and disposal procedures are governed by SC Clerk of Court Manual § 3.1.3 and SCDAH approval schedules. |
| Statutory Preservation & Party Inspection Rights |
Clerk staff advised Plaintiffs on November 19, 2026 that original paper filings from self-represented litigants are retained on-site for 30 days after scanning and then destroyed, citing the 2014 packet. |
S.C. Code Ann. § 14-17-510 requires that the clerk "make a full, fair and correct entry and record of the proceedings" and "file in their proper order original papers in causes instituted or other authorized proceedings and preserve with care all papers, books and furniture pertaining to or connected with his office." S.C. Code Ann. § 14-17-570 mandates that the clerk "shall at all times permit either party to a suit, or his agent or attorney, to inspect or copy, during the pendency of suit, any papers pertaining thereto without charge." |
Access to Justice Builds Stronger Courts
back to top
This filing and accompanying audit are grounded in a straightforward institutional principle: accurate records, transparent dockets, and equal electronic filing access do not burden the judiciary. They make courts faster, less error-prone, and more trusted by the public they serve.
- Self-representation is a structural reality, not an anomaly: A peer-reviewed longitudinal analysis of 5.45 million federal civil cases in Law & Social Inquiry (Mark D. Gough & Emily S. Taylor Poppe, 2020) found that approximately 28% of federal civil filings involve at least one self-represented litigant, accounting for roughly 23% of weighted judicial workload. In South Carolina, access barriers are compounded by attorney scarcity: according to the 2024 ABA National Lawyer Population Survey, South Carolina ranks 50th of 50 states in attorney density at 2.06 lawyers per 1,000 residents compared to 3.81 nationally.
- Procedural friction clogs dockets; parity clears them: Empirical court-modernization studies consistently show that removing administrative bottlenecks saves judicial and clerk time. The Georgia Supreme Court Committee on Civil Justice Report (Dec. 2023) documented that Georgia's Family Law Information Center (FLIC) achieved 76% first-appearance finalization (reversing an 85% pre-FLIC continuance rate), roughly 30% fewer hearings, 10-30 minutes of clerk time saved per interaction, and approximately 50% less courtroom time per assisted case. Similarly, John Greacen's 2009 California San Joaquin Valley benefit-cost study (SRLN) found that self-help workshops cost $0.23 for every $1.00 saved by the courts, while in-hearing assistance saved $2.20 for every $1.00 spent.
- Outside-in "design to demand" via the Most Vulnerable Member (MVM) method: As detailed in the UK Systems Thinking Housing Study precedent on Housing Justice Audit, applying John Seddon's Vanguard Method ("outside-in" design around end-user demand rather than internal bureaucratic barriers) simultaneously improved quality and slashed waste: Tees Valley Housing cut failure demand from 45% to 23% and average repair time from 46 days to 5.9 days; Leeds South East Homes cut vacant-unit turnaround from 50+ days to 25 days; and Preston City Council reduced new-tenant arrears from 43% to 18%. The same outside-in logic applies directly to court administration through the MVM method: when filing and docket systems are designed to work cleanly for the least-resourced litigant, preventable rework disappears for clerks, attorneys, and judges alike.
- Avoiding the "Tragedy of the Commons" in the court system: As mapped in "The Perfect Storm in the Charleston Court System" (Housing Justice Audit Interpretation), a judiciary operates as a finite shared commons (judge time, calendar capacity, clerk bandwidth, and the integrity of truth-seeking). When procedural asymmetry, degraded records, and avoidable motion practice deplete that shared resource faster than it can replenish, institutional reliability erodes for everyone who depends on the courts.
- Public trust and economic vitality depend on reliable, accessible courts: In the National Center for State Courts (NCSC) December 2024 survey, only 25% of voters agreed that state courts do enough to help people navigate the system without an attorney, and voters were split 47%-47% on whether state courts provide equal justice to all. Cross-national economic research reinforces the institutional stake: a 2025 European Economic Review study across 83 countries linked a 1% increase in access to justice to a 0.86-percentage-point gain in five-year GDP-per-capita growth, a 2025 Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization study across 169 countries found judicial delay impedes economic development, and Delaware Judiciary survey materials report that 75% of corporate respondents view a state's litigation environment as likely to affect major business decisions.
- Addressing institutional status bias constructively: As Plaintiffs noted in their February 9, 2026 Hearing Brief, behavioral and organizational research shows that established members of specialized fields can inadvertently default to rigid or defensive responses when non-traditional participants engage with rigorous analysis. Publishing intact, searchable filings and documenting workflow gaps is offered as a constructive contribution to judicial efficiency and record integrity, not an adversarial posture toward court personnel or the legal profession.
Related Resources
back to top