Full text of the filing (47 sections, server-rendered)
Introduction (p. 1-2)
Plaintiffs oppose SAC 181 LLC’s motion seeking a special “AI case management order.” The Supreme Court of South Carolina’s Interim AI Policy does not impose disclosure, certification, or tooling-reporting obligations on lawyers or litigants; it applies to the judiciary and simply reminds parties that signed filings already carry accuracy and confidentiality duties. Rule 11 already governs Parties’ attestations; no further order is necessary or lawful. This motion is a distraction from SAC 181’s unmet discovery duties and a continuation of the defense’s attrition strategy that has forced Plaintiffs to divert time from family, health, and work, and to correct filings made under extraordinary, defense-created time pressure. Defendant filed this motion seeking Court investigation of Plaintiffs' research methods the next business day their discovery responses were due - the same day they filed another frivolous, time - and resource - wasting motion. This motion, like that one, constitutes sanctionable harassment designed to distract from defendants' discovery obligations. This motion has another purpose as well – to cast doubt on Plaintiffs’ ability to litigate against corporate attorneys as pro-se. This contention is refuted by Plaintiff McNeil’s successful litigation - settled for confidential terms - against their own client, SAC 181, LLC (as well as Comcast, Dominion Energy, and Defendant Merdian’s predecessor, Roadstead), Case No. 2021-CP-10-02237. That litigation occurred before ChatGPT (launched November 2022) or Claude (launched March 2023) existed, making defendants' implicit AI theory chronologically impossible. Plaintiffs respectfully request denial of this motion with sanctions under §15-36-10, award of pro se equivalent attorneys' fees, and order directing SAC 181 to immediately comply with outstanding discovery obligations.
Introduction, pp 1-2 (p. 1-2)
INTRODUCTION
Plaintiffs oppose SAC 181 LLC’s motion seeking a special “AI case management order.” The
Supreme Court of South Carolina’s Interim AI Policy does not impose disclosure, certification,
or tooling-reporting obligations on lawyers or litigants; it applies to the judiciary and simply
reminds parties that signed filings already carry accuracy and confidentiality duties.
Rule 11 already governs Parties’ attestations; no further order is necessary or lawful. This
motion is a distraction from SAC 181’s unmet discovery duties and a continuation of the
defense’s attrition strategy that has forced Plaintiffs to divert time from family, health, and
work, and to correct filings made under extraordinary, defense-created time pressure.
Defendant filed this motion seeking Court investigation of Plaintiffs' research methods the next
business day their discovery responses were due - the same day they filed another frivolous,
time - and resource - wasting motion. This motion, like that one, constitutes sanctionable
harassment designed to distract from defendants' discovery obligations.
This motion has another purpose as well – to cast doubt on Plaintiffs’ ability to litigate against
corporate attorneys as pro-se. This contention is refuted by Plaintiff McNeil’s successful
litigation - settled for confidential terms - against their own client, SAC 181, LLC (as well as
Comcast, Dominion Energy, and Defendant Merdian’s predecessor, Roadstead), Case No. 2021-
CP-10-02237. That litigation occurred before ChatGPT (launched November 2022) or Claude
(launched March 2023) existed, making defendants' implicit AI theory chronologically
impossible.
Plaintiffs respectfully request denial of this motion with sanctions under §15-36-10, award of pro
se equivalent attorneys' fees, and order directing SAC 181 to immediately comply with
outstanding discovery obligations.
Caption and Introduction (p. 1-2)
INTRODUCTION
Plaintiffs oppose SAC 181 LLC’s motion seeking a special “AI case management order.” The Supreme Court of South Carolina’s Interim AI Policy does not impose disclosure, certification, or tooling-reporting obligations on lawyers or litigants; it applies to the judiciary and simply reminds parties that signed filings already carry accuracy and confidentiality duties. Rule 11 already governs Parties’ attestations; no further order is necessary or lawful. This motion is a distraction from SAC 181’s unmet discovery duties and a continuation of the defense’s attrition strategy that has forced Plaintiffs to divert time from family, health, and work, and to correct filings made under extraordinary, defense-created time pressure. Defendant filed this motion seeking Court investigation of Plaintiffs' research methods the next business day their discovery responses were due - the same day they filed another frivolous, time - and resource - wasting motion. This motion, like that one, constitutes sanctionable harassment designed to distract from defendants' discovery obligations. This motion has another purpose as well – to cast doubt on Plaintiffs’ ability to litigate against corporate attorneys as pro-se. This contention is refuted by Plaintiff McNeil’s successful litigation - settled for confidential terms - against their own client, SAC 181, LLC (as well as Comcast, Dominion Energy, and Defendant Merdian’s predecessor, Roadstead), Case No. 2021- CP-10-02237. That litigation occurred before ChatGPT (launched November 2022) or Claude (launched March 2023) existed, making defendants' implicit AI theory chronologically impossible. Plaintiffs respectfully request denial of this motion with sanctions under §15-36-10, award of pro se equivalent attorneys' fees, and order directing SAC 181 to immediately comply with outstanding discovery obligations.
Summary of the AI Policy and Existing Law (p. 2-3)
The SC Supreme Court’s Interim AI Policy applies to judicial officers and employees; for lawyers and litigants it provides a general reminder of accuracy and confidentiality obligations and warns to use caution. It does not require Parties to disclose whether, when, or how they use AI, or to certify anything beyond the attestation already inherent in signing pleadings. (Exhibit D – The Supreme Court of South Carolina Re: Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence) Rule 11, SCRCP , already requires that every filing be signed and that counsel/parties certify its factual and legal sufficiency after reasonable inquiry. No further “AI certification” is prescribed or needed. Any order compelling disclosures about specific tools, prompts, or methods is extraneous to accuracy and risks chilling protected, proprietary processes. Courts routinely handle accuracy concerns with existing mechanisms: meet-and-confer, Rule 11, motions to strike, and targeted sanctions where warranted. Creating an extra-process disclosure regime for one side’s tactical purposes is unwarranted and would become a discovery cudgel to stigmatize innovation rather than enhance reliability.
Summary of the AI Policy and Existing Law, p 2 (p. 2-2)
SUMMARY OF THE AI POLICY AND EXISTING LAW
The SC Supreme Court’s Interim AI Policy applies to judicial officers and employees; for
lawyers and litigants it provides a general reminder of accuracy and confidentiality obligations
and warns to use caution. It does not require Parties to disclose whether, when, or how they use
AI, or to certify anything beyond the attestation already inherent in signing pleadings. (Exhibit D
– The Supreme Court of South Carolina Re: Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial
Intelligence)
Rule 11, SCRCP , already requires that every filing be signed and that counsel/parties certify its
factual and legal sufficiency after reasonable inquiry. No further “AI certification” is prescribed
or needed. Any order compelling disclosures about specific tools, prompts, or methods is
extraneous to accuracy and risks chilling protected, proprietary processes.
Courts routinely handle accuracy concerns with existing mechanisms: meet-and-confer, Rule 11,
motions to strike, and targeted sanctions where warranted. Creating an extra-process disclosure
regime for one side’s tactical purposes is unwarranted and would become a discovery cudgel to
stigmatize innovation rather than enhance reliability.
Summary of the AI Policy and Existing Law (p. 2-2)
SUMMARY OF THE AI POLICY AND EXISTING LAW
The SC Supreme Court’s Interim AI Policy applies to judicial officers and employees; for lawyers and litigants it provides a general reminder of accuracy and confidentiality obligations and warns to use caution. It does not require Parties to disclose whether, when, or how they use AI, or to certify anything beyond the attestation already inherent in signing pleadings. (Exhibit D – The Supreme Court of South Carolina Re: Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence) Rule 11, SCRCP , already requires that every filing be signed and that counsel/parties certify its factual and legal sufficiency after reasonable inquiry. No further “AI certification” is prescribed or needed. Any order compelling disclosures about specific tools, prompts, or methods is extraneous to accuracy and risks chilling protected, proprietary processes. Courts routinely handle accuracy concerns with existing mechanisms: meet-and-confer, Rule 11, motions to strike, and targeted sanctions where warranted. Creating an extra-process disclosure regime for one side’s tactical purposes is unwarranted and would become a discovery cudgel to stigmatize innovation rather than enhance reliability.
Work Product Doctrine Protects Litigation Methodology, pp 2-3 (p. 2-3)
Work Product Doctrine Protects Litigation Methodology
South Carolina Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(3) and South Carolina case law establish that "the
attorney work product doctrine protects from discovery documents prepared in anticipation of
litigation, unless a substantial need can be shown." Tobaccoville USA, Inc. v. McMaster, 692
S.E.2d 526, 530 (S.C. 2010). The work product doctrine extends beyond attorney-client
communications to protect "mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories
concerning the litigation." SCRCP 26(b)(3)(B).
The work product doctrine "exists not only to assist the client in obtaining legal advice, but also
to protect the lawyer's interest in privacy during preparation for litigation." The doctrine applies
equally to pro se litigants' litigation preparation materials and methods. Multiple federal district
courts have held or assumed that unrepresented litigants enjoy work product protections. See
Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495 (1947) (foundational work product case).
SAC 181's motion seeks to compel disclosure of precisely the type of information the work
product doctrine protects: Plaintiffs' research methods, drafting processes, tool selection, and
strategic workflows - all "mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories" about
how to most effectively prosecute this litigation. No "substantial need" exists for this
information, as SAC 181 has not and cannot demonstrate how knowing whether Plaintiffs used
particular tools would assist in defending the underlying claims of postal fraud, privacy
violations, and retaliatory conduct.
Work Product Doctrine Protects Litigation Methodology (p. 2-3)
LEGAL FRAMEWORK: WORK PRODUCT PROTECTION AND
FRIVOLOUS MOTION STANDARDS
Work Product Doctrine Protects Litigation Methodology South Carolina Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(3) and South Carolina case law establish that "the attorney work product doctrine protects from discovery documents prepared in anticipation of litigation, unless a substantial need can be shown." Tobaccoville USA, Inc. v. McMaster, 692 S.E.2d 526, 530 (S.C. 2010). The work product doctrine extends beyond attorney-client communications to protect "mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories concerning the litigation." SCRCP 26(b)(3)(B). The work product doctrine "exists not only to assist the client in obtaining legal advice, but also to protect the lawyer's interest in privacy during preparation for litigation." The doctrine applies equally to pro se litigants' litigation preparation materials and methods. Multiple federal district courts have held or assumed that unrepresented litigants enjoy work product protections. See Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495 (1947) (foundational work product case). SAC 181's motion seeks to compel disclosure of precisely the type of information the work product doctrine protects: Plaintiffs' research methods, drafting processes, tool selection, and strategic workflows - all "mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories" about how to most effectively prosecute this litigation. No "substantial need" exists for this information, as SAC 181 has not and cannot demonstrate how knowing whether Plaintiffs used particular tools would assist in defending the underlying claims of postal fraud, privacy violations, and retaliatory conduct.
Legal Framework: Work Product Protection and Frivolous Motion Standards (p. 3-4)
Work Product Doctrine Protects Litigation Methodology South Carolina Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(3) and South Carolina case law establish that "the attorney work product doctrine protects from discovery documents prepared in anticipation of litigation, unless a substantial need can be shown." Tobaccoville USA, Inc. v. McMaster, 692 S.E.2d 526, 530 (S.C. 2010). The work product doctrine extends beyond attorney-client communications to protect "mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories concerning the litigation." SCRCP 26(b)(3)(B). The work product doctrine "exists not only to assist the client in obtaining legal advice, but also to protect the lawyer's interest in privacy during preparation for litigation." The doctrine applies equally to pro se litigants' litigation preparation materials and methods. Multiple federal district courts have held or assumed that unrepresented litigants enjoy work product protections. See Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495 (1947) (foundational work product case). SAC 181's motion seeks to compel disclosure of precisely the type of information the work product doctrine protects: Plaintiffs' research methods, drafting processes, tool selection, and strategic workflows - all "mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories" about how to most effectively prosecute this litigation. No "substantial need" exists for this information, as SAC 181 has not and cannot demonstrate how knowing whether Plaintiffs used particular tools would assist in defending the underlying claims of postal fraud, privacy violations, and retaliatory conduct. South Carolina's Frivolous Motion Standard South Carolina Code §15-36-10 establishes that an attorney or pro se litigant may be sanctioned for "filing a frivolous pleading, motion, or document" where "a reasonable attorney in the same circumstances would believe that the procurement, initiation, continuation, or defense of a civil cause was intended merely to harass or injure the other party" or where the filing is "interposed for delay." S.C. Code Ann. §15-36-10(A)(4)(a)(iii)-(iv). SAC 181's AI motion meets this standard. The Interim AI Policy explicitly does not require the disclosures SAC 181 seeks. The motion was filed the next business day after SAC 181's discovery responses were due, creating a transparent delay tactic. The motion seeks no substantive relief related to case management but instead attempts to stigmatize Plaintiffs' use of modern research tools while diverting attention from SAC 181's discovery obligations and the substantive violations documented in the record.
South Carolina's Frivolous Motion Standard, p 3 (p. 3-3)
South Carolina's Frivolous Motion Standard
South Carolina Code §15-36-10 establishes that an attorney or pro se litigant may be sanctioned
for "filing a frivolous pleading, motion, or document" where "a reasonable attorney in the same
circumstances would believe that the procurement, initiation, continuation, or defense of a civil
cause was intended merely to harass or injure the other party" or where the filing is "interposed
for delay." S.C. Code Ann. §15-36-10(A)(4)(a)(iii)-(iv).
SAC 181's AI motion meets this standard. The Interim AI Policy explicitly does not require the
disclosures SAC 181 seeks. The motion was filed the next business day after SAC 181's
discovery responses were due, creating a transparent delay tactic. The motion seeks no
substantive relief related to case management but instead attempts to stigmatize Plaintiffs' use of
modern research tools while diverting attention from SAC 181's discovery obligations and the
substantive violations documented in the record.
South Carolina's Frivolous Motion Standard (p. 3-3)
South Carolina's Frivolous Motion Standard South Carolina Code §15-36-10 establishes that an attorney or pro se litigant may be sanctioned for "filing a frivolous pleading, motion, or document" where "a reasonable attorney in the same circumstances would believe that the procurement, initiation, continuation, or defense of a civil cause was intended merely to harass or injure the other party" or where the filing is "interposed for delay." S.C. Code Ann. §15-36-10(A)(4)(a)(iii)-(iv). SAC 181's AI motion meets this standard. The Interim AI Policy explicitly does not require the disclosures SAC 181 seeks. The motion was filed the next business day after SAC 181's discovery responses were due, creating a transparent delay tactic. The motion seeks no substantive relief related to case management but instead attempts to stigmatize Plaintiffs' use of modern research tools while diverting attention from SAC 181's discovery obligations and the substantive violations documented in the record.
Procedural Context: Defense Use of Process as a Delay Tactic (p. 4-5)
SAC 181's AI motion continues a documented pattern of defense tactics designed to burden Plaintiffs with procedural skirmishes rather than addressing substantive claims. This pattern constitutes sanctionable conduct under both Rule 11 and S.C. Code §15-36-10. TIMELINE OF CONTINUOUS EXPLOITATION (EXHIBIT A) SAC 181 filed this motion on November 10, 2025—the next business day after their first round of Discovery responses were due (October 3 service = 30 days + 5 days for email/mail service = November 7). Rather than answering Interrogatories about Charles Altman's personal involvement in the retaliatory eviction, providing documents proving or disproving the "renovation" justification for the Notice to Vacate, or producing AppFolio syndication records showing who uploaded Plaintiffs' images to at least 21 rental platforms, SAC 181 instead filed a motion seeking to compel disclosure about Plaintiffs' research tools. This strategic timing violates S.C. Code §15-36-10(A)(4)(a)(iv), which sanctions motions "brought for any purpose other than securing proper discovery, joinder of parties, or adjudication of the claim or defense." The AI motion does not seek discovery, does not affect joinder, and addresses no element of any claim or defense. Its sole purpose is delay and harassment. PATTERN OF FRIVOLOUS AND HARASSING FILINGS The AI motion is the latest in a series of defense filings designed to create procedural burden: - x October 29: SAC 181 filed Motion to Dismiss challenging well-pled statutory claims; x November 7: SAC 181 filed Motion for Protective Order seeking stay of discovery - on the day responses were due; x November 10: SAC 181 filed this AI motion. Each filing diverted Plaintiffs' time from family, health, clients, and the Strategic Thought Leadership platform launch that defendants' conduct interrupted. Each filing required researched opposition briefs prepared under time pressure while managing discovery to four separate defense firms. This cumulative burden explains any minor clerical corrections in Plaintiffs' filings—corrections that SAC 181 now exploits to imply AI misuse, despite having no evidence thereof.
First Amendment Concerns with Compelled Disclosure (p. 3-3)
First Amendment Concerns with Compelled Disclosure SAC 181's requested order would compel Plaintiffs to disclose their research methods, information sources, and analytical processes—core components of how they formulate and express their legal arguments. Such compelled disclosure implicates First Amendment protections for freedom of thought and expression in the litigation context. Courts have recognized that forcing litigants to reveal how they develop legal theories and arguments chills zealous advocacy and innovative legal thinking. The work product doctrine itself reflects these constitutional concerns, recognizing that attorneys and litigants must have a "zone of privacy" in which to prepare their cases without fear of exposing their strategic thinking to opponents. Compelling disclosure of whether, when, and how Plaintiffs use particular research tools or AI assistance would create a precedent enabling discovery into the thought processes behind every legal argument. This is a result fundamentally at odds with both work product protection and free speech principles in advocacy.
Timeline of Continuous Exploitation, pp 4-5 (p. 4-5)
TIMELINE OF CONTINUOUS EXPLOITATION (EXHIBIT A)
SAC 181 filed this motion on November 10, 2025—the next business day after their first round
of Discovery responses were due (October 3 service = 30 days + 5 days for email/mail service =
November 7). Rather than answering Interrogatories about Charles Altman's personal
involvement in the retaliatory eviction, providing documents proving or disproving the
"renovation" justification for the Notice to Vacate, or producing AppFolio syndication records
showing who uploaded Plaintiffs' images to at least 21 rental platforms, SAC 181 instead filed a
motion seeking to compel disclosure about Plaintiffs' research tools.
This strategic timing violates S.C. Code §15-36-10(A)(4)(a)(iv), which sanctions motions
"brought for any purpose other than securing proper discovery, joinder of parties, or adjudication
of the claim or defense." The AI motion does not seek discovery, does not affect joinder, and
addresses no element of any claim or defense. Its sole purpose is delay and harassment.
Legal Deficiencies in SAC 181's Motion (p. 6-7)
SAC 181's Motion Misapplies the Interim AI Policy The Supreme Court of South Carolina's Interim AI Policy (March 25, 2025) applies to "judicial officers and employees of the Judicial Branch." (Exhibit D, §I). The Policy provides guidance for judges using AI tools and reminds attorneys and litigants of existing obligations regarding accuracy and confidentiality. Critically, the Policy imposes no new duties on attorneys or litigants. Section IV states: "Lawyers and litigants are reminded of their existing obligations under the Rules of Professional Conduct and Rules of Civil Procedure to ensure accuracy of factual assertions and legal citations, and to protect confidential information." The Policy does not require disclosure of tools used, certification of AI usage, or any reporting beyond what Rule 11 already mandates—that signed filings are made after reasonable inquiry and are well-founded in fact and law. SAC 181 asks this Court to create obligations the Supreme Court explicitly did not create. The requested order would exceed the Policy's scope and contradict its plain language limiting special duties to the judiciary. No Legal Basis Exists for Compelled Tool Disclosure SAC 181 cites no rule, statute, or case law authorizing courts to compel parties to disclose their research tools, drafting methods, or information sources absent a showing that such disclosure is necessary to prove fraud, fabrication, or other misconduct. SAC 181 makes no such showing here. The motion contains speculation and insinuation but no evidence of: 1. fabricated citations; 2. false factual assertions; 3. plagiarism; 4. violation of any court rule; or 5. any other concrete harm requiring judicial intervention. SAC 181 points to minor corrections in Plaintiffs' filings—corrections that Plaintiffs promptly made and that demonstrate responsible compliance with Rule 11's duty to correct errors when discovered. Absent evidence of actual misconduct, compelling disclosure of litigation methodology would: x Violate work product protection under SCRCP 26(b)(3) x Create precedent for invasive discovery into every litigant's research process x Chill innovative and efficient litigation methods x Discriminate against pro se litigants and small firms using modern tools x Provide no legitimate case management benefit Rule 11 Already Governs Accuracy—Additional Certification Is Unnecessary SCRCP Rule 11 requires that every pleading, motion, or paper be signed, and that the signature constitutes certification that: 1. the signer has read the document; 2. to the best of the signer's knowledge after reasonable inquiry, it is well grounded in fact and warranted by law; and 3. it is not interposed for delay or harassment. Plaintiffs' signature on every filing already provides this certification. SAC 181 has not moved to strike any filing under Rule 12(f), has not sought Rule 11 sanctions, and has not identified any specific false statement requiring correction. The remedy for inaccurate filings is a motion to strike or Rule 11 motion—not a roving commission to investigate research methodology. Creating an additional "AI certification" requirement would: x Duplicate existing Rule 11 obligations without adding protection x Single out one category of research tool for special scrutiny x Require courts to police tool usage rather than filing accuracy x Generate satellite litigation about tool definitions and disclosure scope
Timeline of Continuous Exploitation (p. 3-4)
PROCEDURAL CONTEXT: DEFENSE USE OF PROCESS AS A DELAY
TACTIC
SAC 181's AI motion continues a documented pattern of defense tactics designed to burden Plaintiffs with procedural skirmishes rather than addressing substantive claims. This pattern constitutes sanctionable conduct under both Rule 11 and S.C. Code §15-36-10.
TIMELINE OF CONTINUOUS EXPLOITATION (EXHIBIT A)
SAC 181 filed this motion on November 10, 2025—the next business day after their first round of Discovery responses were due (October 3 service = 30 days + 5 days for email/mail service = November 7). Rather than answering Interrogatories about Charles Altman's personal involvement in the retaliatory eviction, providing documents proving or disproving the "renovation" justification for the Notice to Vacate, or producing AppFolio syndication records showing who uploaded Plaintiffs' images to at least 21 rental platforms, SAC 181 instead filed a motion seeking to compel disclosure about Plaintiffs' research tools. This strategic timing violates S.C. Code §15-36-10(A)(4)(a)(iv), which sanctions motions "brought for any purpose other than securing proper discovery, joinder of parties, or adjudication of the claim or defense." The AI motion does not seek discovery, does not affect joinder, and addresses no element of any claim or defense. Its sole purpose is delay and harassment.
Why the Requested Order Should Be Denied (p. 7-8)
The Interim Policy does not authorize litigant/tool disclosures. The Policy expressly does not impose special duties on attorneys/litigants beyond the extant obligation to ensure accuracy; SAC 181’s proposed order exceeds the Policy’s scope and would invite process abuse and collateral disputes over tooling, prompts, or methods having no necessary nexus to reliability. (Exhibit D) Rule 11 already supplies the standard. The right safeguard is the one already in place - signature attestation after reasonable inquiry. If the Court wishes to say anything, it should reiterate that Parties remain responsible for verifying citations and facts, consistent with current rules—nothing more. Compelled disclosure would chill legitimate, proprietary workflows. Forcing Parties to reveal how they structure research/writing—human or tool-assisted—invades protected work product and confidential competitive methods, while offering no reliability benefit beyond the accuracy assurances already sworn. The motion is yet another time-wasting detour amid discovery noncompliance. With discovery overdue and meet-and-confer shortcomings on record, this motion looks like a public-relations gambit to shift attention away from core obligations. The Court should focus the Parties on production and substantive merits.
Pattern of Frivolous and Harassing Filings (p. 4-4)
PATTERN OF FRIVOLOUS AND HARASSING FILINGS
The AI motion is the latest in a series of defense filings designed to create procedural burden: - x October 29: SAC 181 filed Motion to Dismiss challenging well-pled statutory claims; x November 7: SAC 181 filed Motion for Protective Order seeking stay of discovery - on the day responses were due; x November 10: SAC 181 filed this AI motion. Each filing diverted Plaintiffs' time from family, health, clients, and the Strategic Thought Leadership platform launch that defendants' conduct interrupted. Each filing required researched opposition briefs prepared under time pressure while managing discovery to four separate defense firms. This cumulative burden explains any minor clerical corrections in Plaintiffs' filings—corrections that SAC 181 now exploits to imply AI misuse, despite having no evidence thereof.
Plaintiffs' Unwavering Commitment to Trial and Documentation of Defense Obstruction (p. 8-9)
Exhaustion Does Not Equal Capitulation While Plaintiffs acknowledge that managing this litigation against four law firms, six attorneys, and five defendants over 62 consecutive days has required extraordinary time and energy, resulting in occasional minor clerical errors promptly corrected, this exhaustion in no way diminishes Plaintiffs' absolute commitment to taking this case to trial. Plaintiffs are 100% prepared for trial. Every defense obstruction tactic - every frivolous motion, every missed discovery deadline, every procedural skirmish designed to drain resources - is helpful to Plaintiffs in the sense that it becomes further documented as evidence of the systemic power imbalance this case seeks to remedy. The defendants' conduct proves Plaintiffs' central thesis: that property management companies wield disproportionate power over vulnerable families, and that accountability requires meaningful penalties. Defense Obstruction as Proof of Systemic Problems The pattern of defense conduct in this case - from the initial falsified postal documentation (filename metadata proving September 5, 2025 creation despite August 28, 2025 claimed mailing), through unauthorized image exploitation across 21+ platforms, to the current wave of delay tactics - demonstrates exactly the type of systematic tenant exploitation that South Carolina's landlord-tenant statutes seek to prevent. Each defense filing documented in Exhibit A (Timeline of Continuous Exploitation) serves dual purposes: 1. Immediate: Provides basis for sanctions, fee-shifting, and adverse inferences 2. Strategic: Demonstrates to future juries, regulators, and policymakers how well-resourced defendants deploy procedural complexity to evade accountability The AI motion is particularly instructive. Rather than answer discovery about Charles Altman's knowledge and authorization of the retaliatory eviction, rather than produce documents showing who uploaded Plaintiffs' private images to dozens of rental websites, SAC 181 asks the Court to investigate whether Plaintiffs used AI tools in drafting their opposition briefs. This priority inversion - focusing on Plaintiffs' research methods rather than Defendants' substantive violations - exemplifies the defensive posture that has necessitated this litigation. Trial Preparation Continues Despite Obstruction Plaintiffs are simultaneously: x Preparing comprehensive discovery responses to defendants' interrogatories x Compiling exhibits for trial, including metadata evidence, platform screenshots, and email chains documenting legal misrepresentations x Developing jury presentation materials x Coordinating expert witness analysis of rental market data, property management standards, and digital privacy violations x Building the public-interest Strategic Thought Leadership campaign that will launch soon Every hour diverted to responding to frivolous motions is an hour taken from trial preparation, family care, and business recovery. But Plaintiffs will not be deterred. The defendants' systematic misconduct, the regulators' need for a precedent-setting case, and the thousands of Charleston renters facing similar exploitation all demand that this case reach a jury if settlement proves impossible. Documentation for Appeals and Policy Impact Should defendants prevail on any issue through procedural obstruction rather than merits adjudication, Plaintiffs are documenting a complete appellate record showing how the current system enables well-resourced defendants to exhaust pro se plaintiffs through motion practice designed to avoid addressing substantive claims. This documentation will support: x Appeals preserving meritorious claims for higher court review x Bar complaints against counsel who violated Rule 4.3 x Legislative advocacy for procedural reforms protecting pro se litigants x Scholarly articles and public discourse about access to justice The AI motion will feature prominently in this documentation as a case study in how litigation tactics can be weaponized to shift focus from defendants' documented misconduct (falsified evidence, privacy violations, retaliatory eviction) to plaintiffs' research methodology—creating satellite litigation about tools rather than addressing harms.
Violation of Rule 4.3 Professional Conduct (p. 4-5)
Violation of Rule 4.3 Professional Conduct Defense counsel's communications to Plaintiffs have violated S.C. Rule of Professional Conduct
4.3, which prohibits attorneys from giving legal advice to unrepresented parties whose interests
conflict with the attorney's client. Defense counsel have repeatedly:
1. made technical-sounding objections without legal merit;
2. presented weak positions with false certainty;
3. used condescending language designed to attempt to undermine Plaintiffs' confidence;
and
4. attempted to intimidate Plaintiffs into accepting invalid legal positions.
(Exhibit F, Defense Counsel Communications Demonstration Pattern of Intimidation and Rule
4.3 Violations)
The AI motion continues this pattern by suggesting Plaintiffs cannot produce quality legal work without improper AI assistance, a demeaning assertion unsupported by evidence and contradicted by the sophistication of Plaintiffs' filings, which demonstrate advanced legal research, strategic analysis, and professional presentation. Those filings by Plaintiffs include pre-AI filings in a lawsuit filed against Defendant SAC 181, LLC in 2020-2021 (Exhibit G, Plaintiff’s September 30, 2021 Opposition to Protective Order Demonstrating Pre-AI Litigation Competence)
Request for Judicial Notice/Exhibit Identification (p. 9-10)
Plaintiffs request the Court accept the following exhibits as demonstratives supporting the narrowness of any AI-related order and the context explaining why minor filing corrections arise from defense-created time burdens rather than misuse of technology: Exhibit A: Timeline of Continuous Exploitation showing date-stamped defense conduct and resulting diversion of Plaintiffs’ time and energy, overlapping with discovery skirmishes and compelled corrections. Exhibit B: Get AI Marketing For Us (7/15/25) eBook (PDF), demonstrating Plaintiffs’ human-led schema for responsible amplification: tools assist, but humans creativity leads while human discernment verifies. Exhibit C: Respectful Reach (7/23/25) eBook (PDF), articulating ethical outreach principles evidencing a human-centered approach to communication and verification. Exhibit D: The Supreme Court of South Carolina Interim AI Policy (March 25, 2025), the very policy SAC 181 cites, which applies to the judiciary and does not impose the requested litigant disclosures/certifications. Exhibit E: Plaintiff McNeil’s cessation of social media activity is shown through timeline visual graphs to demonstrate the harm done both by the defendants’ actions that led to this lawsuit and by defense counsel’s time-wasting tactics, resulting in understandable mistakes needing correction due to exhaustion. Exhibit F: Defense Counsel’s emails about AI, voicemail message of October 31, 2025, and analysis showing patterns of attempted intimidation and Rule 4.3 violation. Exhibit G: Plaintiff McNeil’s September 30, 2021 Opposition to Protective Order demonstrates both pre-AI litigation competence and a values-driven approach to litigation like Plaintiffs maintain in this case.
Conclusion (p. 10-11)
The Court should deny SAC 181's motion in its entirety. The Interim AI Policy imposes no litigant disclosure obligations. Rule 11 already governs accuracy. Work product doctrine protects litigation methodology from discovery. The motion violates S.C. Code §15-36-10 as a frivolous filing intended to harass and delay. Plaintiffs further request: 1. Sanctions against SAC 181 and counsel under §15-36-10 for frivolous motion practice; 2. Pro se equivalent of Attorney fees and costs under §15-36-10(G)(1), calculated to include Plaintiffs' time researching and drafting this opposition; 3. An order directing SAC 181 to immediately respond to all outstanding discovery; 4. Such other relief as is just and proper, including findings that this motion violated Rule 4.3 through its demeaning implications about Plaintiffs' capabilities
The Real Workflow: Human-Led Strategy with Tools as Accelerators (p. 5-6)
THE REAL WORKFLOW: HUMAN-LED STRATEGY WITH TOOLS AS
ACCELERATORS
Contrary to SAC 181’s insinuations, Plaintiffs’ methodology is human-led: schema design, double-loop learning, excellence modeling, and ethical narrative architecture, in which modern tools accelerate research and drafting but do not supplant human judgment or Rule 11 responsibility. Plaintiffs’ July 2025 eBooks—published just before the retaliatory eviction— demonstrate an advanced, values-centered system for public-interest thought leadership that integrates ethical outreach and responsible amplification. Those works show what was poised to launch, and what defense conduct derailed. (Exhibit B: “Get AI Marketing For Us” (7/15/25) PDF; Exhibit C: “Respectful Reach” (7/23/25) PDF; Exhibit E) Get AI Marketing For Us (7/15/25): codifies a human-first, schema-based approach to harnessing tools for ethical propagation, with humans setting standards, verifying facts, and structuring arguments - fully consonant with Rule 11 and the Interim AI Policy’s reminder. (Exhibit B) Respectful Reach (7/23/25): articulates norms for principled outreach, reducing harm and increasing public value—again underscoring that the “real engine” is human discernment and verified accuracy, not “AI” as a black box. (Exhibit C: “Respectful Reach” (7/23/25) PDF) These publications, immediately preceding the forced move, corroborate Plaintiffs’ testimony that the defense’s actions interrupted a social-impact launch and forced Plaintiffs to triage time into litigation survival - contributing to occasional, promptly corrected drafting errors unrelated to any technological assistance. The negative impact on Plaintiff McNeil’s time and energy can be further demonstrated by an examination of the supporting social media activity connected with the interrupted launch of the Strategic Thought Leadership + AI-Supported Influence campaign, with both X(Twitter) and LinkedIn accounts showing thriving activity before the forced move and nearly zero after, continuing to stay flatlined during the time-consuming litigation. (Exhibit E, Platform Dropoff Showing Halt of Strategic Thought Leadership Velocity and Exploitation of Plaintiff Time Resources)
Legal Deficiencies in SAC 181's Motion (p. 6-6)
LEGAL DEFICIENCIES IN SAC 181'S MOTION
SAC 181's Motion Misapplies the Interim AI Policy The Supreme Court of South Carolina's Interim AI Policy (March 25, 2025) applies to "judicial officers and employees of the Judicial Branch." (Exhibit D, §I). The Policy provides guidance for judges using AI tools and reminds attorneys and litigants of existing obligations regarding accuracy and confidentiality. Critically, the Policy imposes no new duties on attorneys or litigants. Section IV states: "Lawyers and litigants are reminded of their existing obligations under the Rules of Professional Conduct and Rules of Civil Procedure to ensure accuracy of factual assertions and legal citations, and to protect confidential information." The Policy does not require disclosure of tools used, certification of AI usage, or any reporting beyond what Rule 11 already mandates—that signed filings are made after reasonable inquiry and are well-founded in fact and law. SAC 181 asks this Court to create obligations the Supreme Court explicitly did not create. The requested order would exceed the Policy's scope and contradict its plain language limiting special duties to the judiciary.
No Legal Basis Exists for Compelled Tool Disclosure (p. 6-7)
No Legal Basis Exists for Compelled Tool Disclosure SAC 181 cites no rule, statute, or case law authorizing courts to compel parties to disclose their research tools, drafting methods, or information sources absent a showing that such disclosure is necessary to prove fraud, fabrication, or other misconduct. SAC 181 makes no such showing here. The motion contains speculation and insinuation but no evidence of:
1. fabricated citations;
2. false factual assertions;
3. plagiarism;
4. violation of any court rule; or
5. any other concrete harm requiring judicial intervention.
SAC 181 points to minor corrections in Plaintiffs' filings—corrections that Plaintiffs promptly made and that demonstrate responsible compliance with Rule 11's duty to correct errors when discovered. Absent evidence of actual misconduct, compelling disclosure of litigation methodology would: x Violate work product protection under SCRCP 26(b)(3) x Create precedent for invasive discovery into every litigant's research process x Chill innovative and efficient litigation methods x Discriminate against pro se litigants and small firms using modern tools x Provide no legitimate case management benefit
Conclusion, pp 10-11 (p. 10-11)
CONCLUSION
The Court should deny SAC 181's motion in its entirety. The Interim AI Policy imposes no
litigant disclosure obligations. Rule 11 already governs accuracy. Work product doctrine protects
litigation methodology from discovery. The motion violates S.C. Code §15-36-10 as a frivolous
filing intended to harass and delay.
Plaintiffs further request:
1. Sanctions against SAC 181 and counsel under §15-36-10 for frivolous motion practice;
2. Pro se equivalent of Attorney fees and costs under §15-36-10(G)(1), calculated to include
Plaintiffs' time researching and drafting this opposition;
3. An order directing SAC 181 to immediately respond to all outstanding discovery;
4. Such other relief as is just and proper, including findings that this motion violated Rule
4.3 through its demeaning implications about Plaintiffs' capabilities
Rule 11 Already Governs Accuracy—Additional Certification Is Unnecessary (p. 7-7)
Rule 11 Already Governs Accuracy—Additional Certification Is Unnecessary SCRCP Rule 11 requires that every pleading, motion, or paper be signed, and that the signature constitutes certification that:
1. the signer has read the document;
2. to the best of the signer's knowledge after reasonable inquiry, it is well grounded in fact
and warranted by law; and
3. it is not interposed for delay or harassment.
Plaintiffs' signature on every filing already provides this certification. SAC 181 has not moved to strike any filing under Rule 12(f), has not sought Rule 11 sanctions, and has not identified any specific false statement requiring correction. The remedy for inaccurate filings is a motion to strike or Rule 11 motion—not a roving commission to investigate research methodology. Creating an additional "AI certification" requirement would: x Duplicate existing Rule 11 obligations without adding protection x Single out one category of research tool for special scrutiny x Require courts to police tool usage rather than filing accuracy x Generate satellite litigation about tool definitions and disclosure scope
Exhibit A - Timeline of Continuous Exploitation and Resulting Burden on Pro Se Plaintiffs, pp 12-17 (p. 12-17)
TIMELINE OF CONTINUOUS EXPLOITATION AND RESULTING BURDEN ON
PRO SE PLAINTIFFS
,\. PRIOR LITIGATION HISTORY (2020-2021)
2020 James Christopher McNeil v Comcast Corporate, defendant, et al
• July 14, 2020: Electric shock incident at 181 Gordon
• 2020-2021: Lawsuit filed: McNeil v. Comcast, Dominion Energy, SAC 181, LLC,
and Roadstead Management
• Case No. 2021-CP-10-02237
• November 2021: Confidential settlement with non-disparagement and confidentiality
clauses (specific terms cannot be disclosed per NDA)
• Plaintiff McNeil handled multiple large corporations and their attorneys WITHOUT
AI ([KLELW*\) • ChatGPT launched November 30, 2022, over a year after this case settled.
• The sophistication evident in the current case reflects the same skills demonstrated in
2020-2021 litigation—skills that necessarily developed through human intelligence,
not artificial intelligence that did not yet exist.
• Plaintiffs remained as tenants post-settlement through July 2025
II. PATTERN OF MISCONDUCT BY DEFENDANTS (2022-2025)
2022: Broken Promises and Deceptive Practices
• January-February 2022: Plaintiffs request replacement of broken blinds promised
before lease signing
• February 24, 2022: Property manager confirms willingness to replace blinds
• August 3, 2022: Owner (SAC 181, LLC) rejects replacement despite prior
representations
• 2022-2024: Still images of Plaintiffs and belongings obtained under false pretense of
"inspection"
2024-2025: Escalating Legal Misrepresentations and Retaliatory Eviction
• September 5, 2024: Tara Bayles misrepresents Adam Bayles' ownership role in
company
• April 2-3, 2025: Stephanie Phillips attempts to dictate inspection with less than 24
hours notice
• May 8, 2025: Stephanie falsely claims lease invalid; Plaintiff provides legal correction
• May 23, 2025: Plaintiffs submit good-faith safety proposals (protected tenant activity)
• May 29, 2025: Retaliatory Notice to Vacate issued 6 days after safety proposal—
unsigned "ghost" document
• June 4, 2025: Second NTV email claims "owner has decided to do some renovations"
July 2025: Privacy Violations Through Deception
• July 14, 2025: Stephanie again misrepresents SC landlord-tenant law; Tara Bayles
acknowledges Plaintiff's position is correct but continues to dictate terms
• July 14, 2025: Addison Bayles promises AI will remove Plaintiffs from photos
• July 15, 2025: Matterport virtual tour and still images created showing: Chris McNeil
visible; Rocket (elderly dog in diapers) visible; "Thaut Thought Leadership"
professional branding prominently displayed; personal belongings throughout
• No AI removal performed despite explicit promise
May-July 2025: True Nature of Retaliatory Eviction Becoming Evident
• July 17, 2025: With showings immediately initiated while Plaintiffs still lived there,
making the “renovations” reason untenable, Plaintiffs question defendants' motives in
detailed email citing 5+ year perfect payment history—NO RESPONSE
• July 19, 2025: Rent increased 73% to $5,276/month (2 days after questioning email)
• July 26, 2025: Listing removed from market but privacy-violating images remain live
August-September 2025: Postal Fraud and False Documentation
• August 1, 2025: Forced relocation causes decline in elderly dog Rocket
• August 28, 2025: Defendants claim checks mailed with "EMAILED" postmark stamp
• Filename metadata: "MeridianScanner_20250905_161321.pdf" reveals document
created September 5, 2025—8 days after alleged mailing date
• September 4, 2025: Formal demand letter sent via FedEx
• September 5, 2025: Tara Bayles provides falsified postmark documentation
• September 8, 2025: Settlement deadline expires; defendants refuse to negotiate
• September 10, 2025: Plaintiffs receive actual deposit with legitimate USPS postmark
dated September 8—confirming prior documentation was fabricated
Why the Requested Order Should Be Denied (p. 7-8)
WHY THE REQUESTED ORDER SHOULD BE DENIED
The Interim Policy does not authorize litigant/tool disclosures. The Policy expressly does not impose special duties on attorneys/litigants beyond the extant obligation to ensure accuracy; SAC 181’s proposed order exceeds the Policy’s scope and would invite process abuse and collateral disputes over tooling, prompts, or methods having no necessary nexus to reliability. (Exhibit D) Rule 11 already supplies the standard. The right safeguard is the one already in place - signature attestation after reasonable inquiry. If the Court wishes to say anything, it should reiterate that Parties remain responsible for verifying citations and facts, consistent with current rules— nothing more. Compelled disclosure would chill legitimate, proprietary workflows. Forcing Parties to reveal how they structure research/writing—human or tool-assisted—invades protected work product and confidential competitive methods, while offering no reliability benefit beyond the accuracy assurances already sworn. The motion is yet another time-wasting detour amid discovery noncompliance. With discovery overdue and meet-and-confer shortcomings on record, this motion looks like a public-relations gambit to shift attention away from core obligations. The Court should focus the Parties on production and substantive merits.
Exhibit A - Intensive Litigation Management and Defense Tactics, pp 14-17 (p. 14-17)
III. INTENSIVE LITIGATION MANAGEMENT BY PRO SE PLAINTIFFS
(September-November 2025)
September 9-19, 2025: Case Initiation and Immediate Defense Complexity
• Sept 9: Initial Complaint filed
• Sept 9, 10:17 PM: Eric Pettis emails claiming representation of Meridian
• Sept 10: Pettis confirms representing both Meridian and SAC 181 (conflict of interest)
• Sept 15: Amended Complaint filed adding individual defendants
• Sept 18: Discovery of unauthorized images across 16+ platforms (ultimately 21 sites
discovered, with as many as 30+ more, given ShowMojo’s claim they “Syndicate to
Over 50 Listing Sites”)
• Sept 19: Motion to Disqualify Counsel filed after providing two courtesy warnings to
Pettis
September 21-30, 2025: Evidence Preservation and Escalating Defense Responses
• Sept 21: Evidence preservation notices sent; takedown demands to platforms
• Sept 22: Enhanced Jury Risk Analysis V3 ($2.3M-$10.1M exposure) prepared
• Sept 23: Platforms suddenly add "coming soon" graphics covering evidence
• Sept 25: Rule 408 protected settlement offer to SAC 181 with September 29 deadline
• Sept 29: IPG insurance contacts Plaintiffs 90 minutes before Answer deadline;
requests extension for answering Amended Complaint
• Sept 29: Rule 408 protected settlement offer deadline expires without response from
SAC 181
• Sept 30: Two motions filed (Expedited Hearing on Disqualification; Compel
Insurance Disclosure)
October 2-10, 2025: Discovery Preparation and Multiple Counsel Transitions
• Oct 2: Comprehensive evidence preservation demand with metadata specifications
• Oct 3: First round of Discovery served: 15 Interrogatories and 13-15 Document
Requests per defendant, customized for each party
• Oct 8: Enhanced Jury Risk Analysis V5 prepared and served under Rule 408
• Oct 9: New counsel Alicia Bolyard appears for Meridian defendants; files Answer
with crossclaims containing admission of managing "multiple properties"
(contradicting record showing SAC 181 owns only one property)
• Oct 10: Pettis withdraws; another settlement offer to SAC 181 expires without
response
• Oct 11: Personal service on Adam Bayles as RA of MRG Investing Company
October 15-31, 2025: Continued Intensive Litigation Activity
• Oct 15: New counsel Kevin O'Brien and Justine Tate appear for SAC 181
• Oct 17: Amended Rule 11 Motion prepared addressing new bad faith conduct served
to Meridian Counsel Bolyard, allowing time for cure (no cure attempted)
• Oct 24: Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint (with entire 2AC as
exhibit); discovery of 5 additional platforms with Plaintiffs' images (total now 21
sites)
• Oct 29: Emergency Motion for Rule 11 Sanctions filed against Bolyard's Answer
• Oct 29: SAC 181's Motion to Dismiss filed
• Oct 30: Response in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss filed (same day turnaround)
• Oct 31: First round of Requests for Admission served to all defendants except MRG
November 2025: Defense Obstruction Tactics and Frivolous Filings
• Nov 4: Third counsel Jeff Kuykendall appears for MRG; files Motion to Dismiss
• Nov 6: Defense attorneys challenge validity of October 3 Discovery service via
multiple emails; Plaintiffs file Notice of Prior Service and Computed Deadlines to
clarify record
• Nov 7: SAC 181 attorneys file Motion for Protective Order and Stay of Discovery on
day their Discovery responses are due
• Nov 7: Bolyard misses Discovery deadline for Meridian defendants
• Nov 10: SAC 181 attorneys file Motion for Case Management Order for Use of AI, a
frivolous filing implying the quality of Plaintiffs' pro se work is only due to AI. This
contention is chronologically refuted by Plaintiff's successful 2020-2021 litigation
(Case No. 2021-CP-10-02237) against their own client SAC 181, along with Comcast,
Dominion Energy, and Meridian's predecessor Roadstead, before ChatGPT or Claude
existed
Defense Obstruction as Proof of Systemic Problems (p. 8-8)
Defense Obstruction as Proof of Systemic Problems The pattern of defense conduct in this case - from the initial falsified postal documentation (filename metadata proving September 5, 2025 creation despite August 28, 2025 claimed mailing), through unauthorized image exploitation across 21+ platforms, to the current wave of delay tactics - demonstrates exactly the type of systematic tenant exploitation that South Carolina's landlord-tenant statutes seek to prevent. Each defense filing documented in Exhibit A (Timeline of Continuous Exploitation) serves dual purposes:
1. Immediate: Provides basis for sanctions, fee-shifting, and adverse inferences
2. Strategic: Demonstrates to future juries, regulators, and policymakers how well-resourced
defendants deploy procedural complexity to evade accountability The AI motion is particularly instructive. Rather than answer discovery about Charles Altman's knowledge and authorization of the retaliatory eviction, rather than produce documents showing who uploaded Plaintiffs' private images to dozens of rental websites, SAC 181 asks the Court to investigate whether Plaintiffs used AI tools in drafting their opposition briefs. This priority inversion - focusing on Plaintiffs' research methods rather than Defendants' substantive violations - exemplifies the defensive posture that has necessitated this litigation.
Exhibit D - Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence, pp 51-55 (p. 51-55)
The Supreme Court of South Carolina
Re: Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial
Intelligence
Appellate Case No. 2025-000043
ORDER
In response to the increasing use of artificial intelligence systems in legal research
and applications, and in recognition of the potential benefits and risks in utilizing
this new technology within the South Carolina Judicial Branch, I find it necessary
to issue this Interim Policy regarding the appropriate use and limitations on the use
of generative artificial intelligence tools and systems by the judiciary and court
personnel. This policy seeks to ensure the responsible and secure integration of
these technologies into the judiciary, while safeguarding the integrity of judicial
proceedings and protecting the privacy and rights of parties and others involved in
matters in all courts in the Unified Judicial System.
(a) Application. This Interim Policy applies to all Judicial Officers and Employees
of the South Carolina Judicial Branch. Judicial Officers and Employees includes
Justices, judges, attorneys, law clerks, administrative assistants, interns, externs,
temporary employees, paralegals, and all other employees or volunteers within the
Branch regardless of whether they are compensated by state or local funds,
including information technology professionals.
(d) Use of AI by Lawyers and Litigants in Matters.
(1) While this Interim Policy does not specifically address the use of
Generative AI by lawyers and litigants, lawyers and litigants are reminded
that they are responsible to ensure the accuracy of all work product and must
use caution when relying on any output of Generative AI.
(2) Lawyers in particular must ensure that the use Generative AI does not
compromise client confidentiality or otherwise violate the South Carolina
Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 407, SCACR.
(e) Ongoing Evaluation and Future Policy Development. This Interim Policy
shall remain in effect until further Order of the Chief Justice or the Supreme Court.
s/John W. Kittredge
John W. Kittredge
Chief Justice of South Carolina
March 25, 2025
Columbia, South Carolina
Documentation for Appeals and Policy Impact (p. 9-9)
Documentation for Appeals and Policy Impact Should defendants prevail on any issue through procedural obstruction rather than merits adjudication, Plaintiffs are documenting a complete appellate record showing how the current system enables well-resourced defendants to exhaust pro se plaintiffs through motion practice designed to avoid addressing substantive claims. This documentation will support: x Appeals preserving meritorious claims for higher court review x Bar complaints against counsel who violated Rule 4.3 x Legislative advocacy for procedural reforms protecting pro se litigants x Scholarly articles and public discourse about access to justice The AI motion will feature prominently in this documentation as a case study in how litigation tactics can be weaponized to shift focus from defendants' documented misconduct (falsified evidence, privacy violations, retaliatory eviction) to plaintiffs' research methodology—creating satellite litigation about tools rather than addressing harms.
Exhibit F - Tate Email Warnings, pp 64-67 (p. 64-67)
From: Justine Tate (5311)
Sent: Monday, November 3, 2025 3:22 PM
To: Kevin O'Brien (5302); chris thaut.io; Alicia Bolyard; C&M McNeil;
cmanning@rlattorneys.com
Cc: Kelsi Sigler; Kaylie Stapleton
Subject: RE: Voicemail Regarding McNeil & Poyer v. SAC 181, LLC et al. (Case No. 2025-
CP-10-05095)
Hi Mr. McNeil,
We respond to your note below as follows.
First, yes, we are aware of pro se plainti Ư s’ response opposing our Motion to Dismiss. We
filed our Motion to Dismiss in response to the only currently pending pleading on record.
Your motion for leave to amend your complaint does not moot our Motion to Dismiss.
With regard to your Motion for Leave to Amend, we plan to oppose such motion and
believe that the Court will deny it (based upon futility as it would be subject to a motion to
dismiss and/or for a more definite statement).
Second, as for discovery purportedly issued by pro se plainti Ư s, it is our understanding
that, at some point, pro se plainti Ư s attempted to issue written discovery to Defendant
SAC in this matter. As we advised you in a prior e-mail, it has not been served upon us as
counsel of record to date (other than the Requests for Admission issued on 10/31) and
thus, we wanted to note that we do not consider any such written discovery served on
SAC. It is our further understanding that, at some point in time, such requests were
emailed to Mr. Pettis, who is not counsel of record for SAC (and never was) because he
never made a notice of appearance in this case. There is also no Certificate of Service
reflecting service on us as counsel for Defendant SAC or Defendant SAC’s registered
agent. Thus, any such e-mail correspondence attempting to serve discovery did not start
the 35 day clock. As counsel of record for Defendant SAC, we are happy to accept service
of any written discovery pro se plainti Ư s wish to propound on Defendant SAC going
forward (in addition to the Requests for Admission), should you elect to do so.
We reached out to you last week to short cut some of these things, but if you and/or Ms.
Poyer do not wish to chat with us, so be it. Below is what we planned to discuss.
1. We would caution the continued and purported use of SCRCP Rule 11 allegations in
motions and pleadings when it is not a rule that you understand and has very
particular consequences.
2. We caution you and Ms. Poyer labeling filed motions as “emergency” motions. We
are confident that the Court does not view your motions as an “emergency.” This is a
very specific designation saved for unique and particular circumstances, including grave risk to life and limb. That is not the case here. We are certain that a
Court not only would agree with us, but also does not take kindly to such an overuse of this designation. Please consider this our good faith conference on the
issue. We request that you withdraw all alleged motions that have been labeled as
“emergency.” If you choose not to do so, and we reserve all rights to seek
appropriate recourse (or the Court may act on its own).
3. We are not prepared to discuss any potential settlements at the policy limits or
above those limits for many reasons, but, namely, there is absolutely nothing to
suggest that pro se plainti Ư s’ claims are valued anywhere near the policy limits in
this case, irrespective of any purported “jury risk analysis” you may have presented.
We do not agree with this analysis, nor have we seen any such analysis in our legal
research. In that regard, please understand that some of the documents you have
had created (we expect from AI) and some of the jargon you are using thinking that it
is common amongst lawyers in the area are not actually documents and/or jargon
used.
4. In that at regard, we caution that AI generated documents and any attempted use of
AI generated information or legal analysis or use of verbiage in the legal profession
are not always correct/accurate. Thus, we further caution your and Ms. Poyer’s use
of AI generated information in papers filed with the Court. We also encourage you to
research what has happened to lawyers in this profession who have used AI
generated research and information in their filings and the ramifications the Court
has imposed as a result. We intend to ask the Court to require certifications
regarding any use by anyone in this case of AI for anything filed with the Court or
served under the Rules of Civil Procedure.
If, upon reading this, you have changed you mind and would like to or are willing to talk,
we would still be happy to discuss these issues and try to streamline things. If not, you
have been advised of the above outline of issues we intended to discuss.
Thanks,
Justine
Request for Judicial Notice/Exhibit Identification (p. 9-10)
REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE/EXHIBIT IDENTIFICATION
Plaintiffs request the Court accept the following exhibits as demonstratives supporting the narrowness of any AI-related order and the context explaining why minor filing corrections arise from defense-created time burdens rather than misuse of technology: Exhibit A: Timeline of Continuous Exploitation showing date-stamped defense conduct and resulting diversion of Plaintiffs’ time and energy, overlapping with discovery skirmishes and compelled corrections. Exhibit B: Get AI Marketing For Us (7/15/25) eBook (PDF), demonstrating Plaintiffs’ human- led schema for responsible amplification: tools assist, but humans creativity leads while human discernment verifies. Exhibit C: Respectful Reach (7/23/25) eBook (PDF), articulating ethical outreach principles evidencing a human-centered approach to communication and verification. Exhibit D: The Supreme Court of South Carolina Interim AI Policy (March 25, 2025), the very policy SAC 181 cites, which applies to the judiciary and does not impose the requested litigant disclosures/certifications. Exhibit E: Plaintiff McNeil’s cessation of social media activity is shown through timeline visual graphs to demonstrate the harm done both by the defendants’ actions that led to this lawsuit and by defense counsel’s time-wasting tactics, resulting in understandable mistakes needing correction due to exhaustion. Exhibit F: Defense Counsel’s emails about AI, voicemail message of October 31, 2025, and analysis showing patterns of attempted intimidation and Rule 4.3 violation. Exhibit G: Plaintiff McNeil’s September 30, 2021 Opposition to Protective Order demonstrates both pre-AI litigation competence and a values-driven approach to litigation like Plaintiffs maintain in this case.
Conclusion and Requested Relief (p. 10-11)
CONCLUSION
The Court should deny SAC 181's motion in its entirety. The Interim AI Policy imposes no litigant disclosure obligations. Rule 11 already governs accuracy. Work product doctrine protects litigation methodology from discovery. The motion violates S.C. Code §15-36-10 as a frivolous filing intended to harass and delay. Plaintiffs further request:
1. Sanctions against SAC 181 and counsel under §15-36-10 for frivolous motion practice;
2. Pro se equivalent of Attorney fees and costs under §15-36-10(G)(1), calculated to include
Plaintiffs' time researching and drafting this opposition;
3. An order directing SAC 181 to immediately respond to all outstanding discovery;
4. Such other relief as is just and proper, including findings that this motion violated Rule
4.3 through its demeaning implications about Plaintiffs' capabilities
Respectfully submitted this 13 th day of November, 2025. James C. (“Chris”) McNeil, Pro Se P.O. Box 30386, Charleston, SC 29417 chris@thaut.io Meaghan Poyer, Pro Se P.O. Box 30386, Charleston, SC 29417 mcneilandpoyer@gmail.com
Exhibit F - McNeil Response, pp 70-71 (p. 70-71)
From: chris thaut.io
Sent: Monday, November 3, 2025 4:40 PM
To: Justine Tate (5311); Kevin O'Brien (5302); Alicia Bolyard; C&M McNeil;
cmanning@rlattorneys.com
Cc: Kelsi Sigler; Kaylie Stapleton
Subject: RE: Voicemail Regarding McNeil & Poyer v. SAC 181, LLC et al. (Case No. 2025-
CP-10-05095)
Ms. Tate,
Thank you for your November 3, 2025, 3:22 PM email.
Discovery Service to SAC 181, LLC:
Your email states that discovery to SAC 181, LLC "has not been served upon us as counsel of record to
date (other than the Requests for Admission issued on 10/31)" and that you "do not consider any such
written discovery served on SAC."
Your position is factually incorrect and legally unfounded.
SAC 181, LLC's First Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents was properly
served on October 3, 2025, thirty-one (31) days ago, to counsel then of record for SAC 181, LLC, in full
compliance with the South Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure.
I will provide complete documentation demonstrating this, along with supporting legal authority, by end
of business tomorrow (Tuesday, November 4, 2025). This documentation will demonstrate that:
SAC 181, LLC had counsel of record at the time of service;
Service was made in compliance with applicable rules;
Responses are overdue under the applicable deadline; and
Whether Phelps Dunbar received forwarded discovery materials from prior counsel is irrelevant to
service validity.
Regarding Your AI-Related Cautions:
I note with considerable irony your concerns about AI usage in legal filings.
My professional background includes not only strategic consulting on AI implementation, but also direct
programming work with AI APIs—specifically developing systems that use strategic schema markup to
train AI models as advocates for specific thought leadership positions. This includes work on systemic
issues such as housing crisis dynamics and policy solutions and Thought Leadership Positions like
"Rental property ownership requires responsible stewardship since it involved essential shelter for the
vulnerable" to replace old thinking like "Rental properties are just passive investment".
Regarding Other Matters:
We have received your various cautions and positions regarding procedural issues. We will address
those as (and if) appropriate.
I will send my detailed response with exhibits and legal authority by 12:00 Noon Wednesday (November
5, 2025).
In the interim, I must attend to client work that has been necessarily delayed while addressing this
litigation.
Respectfully,
Chris McNeil
James C. McNeil & Meaghan Poyer
Plainti Ư s Pro Se
PO Box 30386
Charleston, SC 29417
Email: chris@thaut.io; mcneilandpoyer@gmail.com
Telephone: (843) 818-3495
Prior Litigation History (2020-2021) (p. 13-13)
I. PRIOR LITIGATION HISTORY (2020-2021)
2020 James Christopher McNeil v Comcast Corporate, defendant, et al • July 14, 2020: Electric shock incident at 181 Gordon • 2020-2021: Lawsuit filed: McNeil v. Comcast, Dominion Energy, SAC 181, LLC, and Roadstead Management • Case No. 2021-CP-10-02237 • November 2021: Confidential settlement with non-disparagement and confidentiality clauses (specific terms cannot be disclosed per NDA) • Plaintiff McNeil handled multiple large corporations and their attorneys WITHOUT AI • ChatGPT launched November 30, 2022, over a year after this case settled. • The sophistication evident in the current case reflects the same skills demonstrated in 2020-2021 litigation—skills that necessarily developed through human intelligence, not artificial intelligence that did not yet exist. • Plaintiffs remained as tenants post-settlement through July 2025
Exhibit G - Plaintiff's September 30, 2021 Opposition to Protective Order, pp 74-78 (p. 74-78)
EXHIBIT * :
PLAINTIFF'S SEPTEMBER 30, 2021 OPPOSITION TO
PROTECTIVE ORDER DEMONSTRATING PRE-AI
LITIGATION COMPETENCE
2024-2025 Escalating Legal Misrepresentations and Retaliatory Eviction (p. 13-14)
2024-2025: Escalating Legal Misrepresentations and Retaliatory Eviction • September 5, 2024: Tara Bayles misrepresents Adam Bayles' ownership role in company • April 2-3, 2025: Stephanie Phillips attempts to dictate inspection with less than 24 hours notice • May 8, 2025: Stephanie falsely claims lease invalid; Plaintiff provides legal correction • May 23, 2025: Plaintiffs submit good-faith safety proposals (protected tenant activity) • May 29, 2025: Retaliatory Notice to Vacate issued 6 days after safety proposal— unsigned "ghost" document • June 4, 2025: Second NTV email claims "owner has decided to do some renovations" July 2025: Privacy Violations Through Deception • July 14, 2025: Stephanie again misrepresents SC landlord-tenant law; Tara Bayles acknowledges Plaintiff's position is correct but continues to dictate terms • July 14, 2025: Addison Bayles promises AI will remove Plaintiffs from photos • July 15, 2025: Matterport virtual tour and still images created showing: Chris McNeil visible; Rocket (elderly dog in diapers) visible; "Thaut Thought Leadership" professional branding prominently displayed; personal belongings throughout • No AI removal performed despite explicit promise
Postal Fraud and False Documentation (p. 14-14)
August-September 2025: Postal Fraud and False Documentation • August 1, 2025: Forced relocation causes decline in elderly dog Rocket • August 28, 2025: Defendants claim checks mailed with "EMAILED" postmark stamp • Filename metadata: "MeridianScanner_20250905_161321.pdf" reveals document created September 5, 2025—8 days after alleged mailing date • September 4, 2025: Formal demand letter sent via FedEx • September 5, 2025: Tara Bayles provides falsified postmark documentation • September 8, 2025: Settlement deadline expires; defendants refuse to negotiate • September 10, 2025: Plaintiffs receive actual deposit with legitimate USPS postmark dated September 8—confirming prior documentation was fabricated
September-November 2025 Litigation Activity (p. 14-15)
September 9-19, 2025: Case Initiation and Immediate Defense Complexity • Sept 9: Initial Complaint filed • Sept 9, 10:17 PM: Eric Pettis emails claiming representation of Meridian • Sept 10: Pettis confirms representing both Meridian and SAC 181 (conflict of interest) • Sept 15: Amended Complaint filed adding individual defendants • Sept 18: Discovery of unauthorized images across 16+ platforms (ultimately 21 sites discovered, with as many as 30+ more, given ShowMojo’s claim they “Syndicate to Over 50 Listing Sites”) • Sept 19: Motion to Disqualify Counsel filed after providing two courtesy warnings to Pettis September 21-30, 2025: Evidence Preservation and Escalating Defense Responses • Sept 21: Evidence preservation notices sent; takedown demands to platforms • Sept 22: Enhanced Jury Risk Analysis V3 ($2.3M-$10.1M exposure) prepared • Sept 23: Platforms suddenly add "coming soon" graphics covering evidence • Sept 25: Rule 408 protected settlement offer to SAC 181 with September 29 deadline • Sept 29: IPG insurance contacts Plaintiffs 90 minutes before Answer deadline; requests extension for answering Amended Complaint • Sept 29: Rule 408 protected settlement offer deadline expires without response from
SAC 181
• Sept 30: Two motions filed (Expedited Hearing on Disqualification; Compel Insurance Disclosure) October 2-10, 2025: Discovery Preparation and Multiple Counsel Transitions • Oct 2: Comprehensive evidence preservation demand with metadata specifications • Oct 3: First round of Discovery served: 15 Interrogatories and 13-15 Document Requests per defendant, customized for each party • Oct 8: Enhanced Jury Risk Analysis V5 prepared and served under Rule 408 • Oct 9: New counsel Alicia Bolyard appears for Meridian defendants; files Answer with crossclaims containing admission of managing "multiple properties" (contradicting record showing SAC 181 owns only one property) • Oct 10: Pettis withdraws; another settlement offer to SAC 181 expires without response
November 2025 Defense Obstruction Tactics and Frivolous Filings (p. 15-15)
November 2025: Defense Obstruction Tactics and Frivolous Filings • Nov 4: Third counsel Jeff Kuykendall appears for MRG; files Motion to Dismiss • Nov 6: Defense attorneys challenge validity of October 3 Discovery service via multiple emails; Plaintiffs file Notice of Prior Service and Computed Deadlines to clarify record • Nov 7: SAC 181 attorneys file Motion for Protective Order and Stay of Discovery on day their Discovery responses are due • Nov 7: Bolyard misses Discovery deadline for Meridian defendants • Nov 10: SAC 181 attorneys file Motion for Case Management Order for Use of AI, a frivolous filing implying the quality of Plaintiffs' pro se work is only due to AI. This contention is chronologically refuted by Plaintiff's successful 2020-2021 litigation (Case No. 2021-CP-10-02237) against their own client SAC 181, along with Comcast, Dominion Energy, and Meridian's predecessor Roadstead, before ChatGPT or Claude existed
Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (p. 52-55)
The Supreme Court of South Carolina
Re: Interim Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence
Appellate Case No. 2025-000043
ORDER
In response to the increasing use of artificial intelligence systems in legal research and applications, and in recognition of the potential benefits and risks in utilizing this new technology within the South Carolina Judicial Branch, I find it necessary to issue this Interim Policy regarding the appropriate use and limitations on the use of generative artificial intelligence tools and systems by the judiciary and court personnel. This policy seeks to ensure the responsible and secure integration of these technologies into the judiciary, while safeguarding the integrity of judicial proceedings and protecting the privacy and rights of parties and others involved in matters in all courts in the Unified Judicial System.
(d) Use of AI by Lawyers and Litigants in Matters.
(1) While this Interim Policy does not specifically address the use of Generative AI by lawyers and litigants, lawyers and litigants are reminded that they are responsible to ensure the accuracy of all work product and must use caution when relying on any output of Generative AI.
(2) Lawyers in particular must ensure that the use Generative AI does not compromise client confidentiality or otherwise violate the South Carolina Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 407, SCACR.
(e) Ongoing Evaluation and Future Policy Development. This Interim Policy shall remain in effect until further Order of the Chief Justice or the Supreme Court.
s/John W. Kittredge John W. Kittredge Chief Justice of South Carolina
March 25, 2025 Columbia, South Carolina
Justine Tate Email Warnings (p. 61-65)
Communication 2: Tate Email "Warnings" (November 3, 2025) FROM: Justine Tate, Phelps Dunbar LLP TO: James McNeil, Meaghan Poyer DATE: November 3, 2025
RELEVANT EXCERPTS WITH ANALYSIS:
EXCERPT 1 - Rule 11 "Warning": "We would caution the continued and purported use of SCRCP Rule 11 allegations in motions and pleadings when it is not a rule that you understand and has very particular consequences."
EXCERPT 2 - "Emergency Motion" Discouragement: "We caution you and Ms. Poyer labeling filed motions as 'emergency' motions. We are confident that the Court does not view your motions as an 'emergency.' This is a very specific designation saved for unique and particular circumstances, including grave risk to life and limb."
EXCERPT 3 - AI Usage "Caution": "We caution that AI generated documents and any attempted use of AI generated information or legal analysis or use of verbiage in the legal profession are not always correct/accurate. Thus, we further caution your and Ms. Poyer's use of AI generated information in papers filed with the Court."
1. We would caution the continued and purported use of SCRCP Rule 11 allegations in
motions and pleadings when it is not a rule that you understand and has very particular consequences.
2. We caution you and Ms. Poyer labeling filed motions as “emergency” motions. We
are confident that the Court does not view your motions as an “emergency.” This is a very specific designation saved for unique and particular circumstances, including grave risk to life and limb. That is not the case here. We are certain that a Court not only would agree with us, but also does not take kindly to such an overuse of this designation. Please consider this our good faith conference on the issue. We request that you withdraw all alleged motions that have been labeled as “emergency.” If you choose not to do so, and we reserve all rights to seek appropriate recourse (or the Court may act on its own).
3. We are not prepared to discuss any potential settlements at the policy limits or
above those limits for many reasons, but, namely, there is absolutely nothing to suggest that pro se plainti Ư s’ claims are valued anywhere near the policy limits in this case, irrespective of any purported “jury risk analysis” you may have presented. We do not agree with this analysis, nor have we seen any such analysis in our legal research. In that regard, please understand that some of the documents you have had created (we expect from AI) and some of the jargon you are using thinking that it is common amongst lawyers in the area are not actually documents and/or jargon used.
4. In that at regard, we caution that AI generated documents and any attempted use of
AI generated information or legal analysis or use of verbiage in the legal profession are not always correct/accurate. Thus, we further caution your and Ms. Poyer’s use of AI generated information in papers filed with the Court. We also encourage you to research what has happened to lawyers in this profession who have used AI generated research and information in their filings and the ramifications the Court has imposed as a result. We intend to ask the Court to require certifications regarding any use by anyone in this case of AI for anything filed with the Court or served under the Rules of Civil Procedure.
McNeil Response Regarding AI-Related Cautions (p. 68-71)
Communication 3: McNeil Response (November 3, 2025) FROM: James C. McNeil TO: Justine Tate DATE: November 3, 2025
RELEVANT EXCERPT:
Regarding Your AI-Related Cautions: I note with considerable irony your concerns about AI usage in legal filings. My professional background includes not only strategic consulting on AI implementation, but also direct programming work with AI APIs—specifically developing systems that use strategic schema markup to train AI models as advocates for specific thought leadership positions. This includes work on systemic issues such as housing crisis dynamics and policy solutions and Thought Leadership Positions like "Rental property ownership requires responsible stewardship since it involved essential shelter for the vulnerable" to replace old thinking like "Rental properties are just passive investment". Regarding Other Matters: We have received your various cautions and positions regarding procedural issues. We will address those as (and if) appropriate. I will send my detailed response with exhibits and legal authority by 12:00 Noon Wednesday (November 5, 2025). In the interim, I must attend to client work that has been necessarily delayed while addressing this litigation.
Plaintiff's September 30, 2021 Opposition to Protective Order (p. 74-78)
EXHIBIT * :
PLAINTIFF'S SEPTEMBER 30, 2021 OPPOSITION TO
PROTECTIVE ORDER DEMONSTRATING PRE-AI
LITIGATION COMPETENCE